Guide for Thumbtack Pros
Thumbtack vs Angi (and HomeAdvisor): a pro's comparison
For a pro, Thumbtack vs Angi vs HomeAdvisor is a two-way choice, because HomeAdvisor and Angi are one company and HomeAdvisor's pro product now runs as Angi Leads. Neither Thumbtack nor Angi publishes a rate sheet, so the useful comparison is in the rules: how the price is set, when you get billed, what happens to a bad lead, and whether you sign an annual contract.
Updated November 11, 2026 · Checked against the Thumbtack Help Center
The short answer
For most solo pros and small crews who want to control spend week to week without a contract, Thumbtack is the safer place to start. Angi is worth a test if you work in a home trade, see real demand in your ZIP codes, and stay on pay-per-lead so you keep the right to request lead credits.
- Commitment: as of November 2026, Thumbtack charges no join, monthly or annual fee (Thumbtack for Pros). Angi offers pay-per-lead billed weekly and annual subscriptions (Angi Help).
- Price control: on Thumbtack you set an exact price per service or a minimum and maximum per trade, depending on your account (Set lead prices, Smarter matching). Angi sets lead fees by task, location and demand and publishes no rate card (Angi Help).
- Customers who go silent: Thumbtack refunds a lead automatically when the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours and you met four response rules (Thumbtack Help). Angi gives no credit when a homeowner never answers, hires someone else or is only shopping (Angi Help).
- Categories: Angi is a home services marketplace. Thumbtack lists 500+ project categories as of November 2026, including events, lessons and wellness (Thumbtack About).
(Homeowners: asking for quotes is free on both sites. Everything below is about what pros pay.)
Are Angi and HomeAdvisor the same thing?
On the pro side, yes. Angie's List and HomeAdvisor sit under one parent company, Angi Inc. Angie's List was renamed Angi in March 2021, and HomeAdvisor's pro product became Angi Leads, according to Angi's annual report as summarized by Echvo and ProLicensed.
The two companies report very different numbers:
- Thumbtack was founded in 2008 in San Francisco and is led by CEO Marco Zappacosta (Wikipedia, 2024 Fact Sheet). Its about page lists 300,000+ local businesses and 90 million+ projects started (Thumbtack About, read November 2026). In April 2026, CFO Larry Roseman said Thumbtack had connected 4.5 million+ customers with 300,000+ pros over the past year (Thumbtack LinkedIn).
- Angi reported for Q3 2026 that it had wound down its legacy advertising product, averaged about 101,000 monthly active US pros (down 14.4% year over year) and delivered 4.5 million leads (down 17.6%) (TradingKey, MarketBeat).
HomeAdvisor also has an FTC case behind it. In April 2023 the FTC finalized an order under which HomeAdvisor pays up to $7.2 million and may not misrepresent lead quality, such as calling leads "ready to hire." The FTC complaint cited a $287.99 annual membership (FTC order PDF). The order settled the allegations, and HomeAdvisor did not admit wrongdoing, per TechCrunch.
Side-by-side: how each charges you
| Rule (as of November 2026) | Thumbtack | Angi (Angi Leads / HomeAdvisor) |
|---|---|---|
| Join or membership fee | $0 to join; no monthly or annual fee (Thumbtack for Pros). | Not published; pay-per-lead and annual plans (Angi Help). |
| How price is set | Exact price per service, or a min to max range per trade on smarter-matching accounts (Set prices, Smarter matching). | By task, location and demand (Angi Help). |
| When you are charged | Leads: automatically when the customer contacts you. Opportunities: only if the customer replies (Types of leads). | When you and the homeowner are matched, whether or not you open or respond (Angi Help). |
| How many pros | Up to 5 pros from search in the first 4 hours, more after that (Quality Commitment Terms). | No more than 5 pros per request (Angi Help). |
| Budget | Weekly budget resets Monday; the last lead can go over by the lower of 40% or $40 + 2% of budget (Set budget). Opportunities are billed outside it. | Pay-per-lead billed weekly against a monthly budget; subscription budgets set annually; Opportunities charged on top (Angi Help). |
| Contract and screening | No contract (Thumbtack for Pros); owner background check at signup and every year (Background checks). | Subscriptions are annual (Angi Help). |
Three billing rules catch pros off guard:
- You can pay for leads you never opened. Angi charges "whether or not you open or respond" (Angi Help). Thumbtack leads in the "For you" tab are also charged automatically when the customer contacts you (Pay for leads). Thumbtack Opportunities work differently: quoting is free and you pay only if the customer replies. They close after 48 hours, once 5 pros have shown interest, or if the job is canceled.
- Thumbtack has more lead types and toggles. Preset jobs, including Lowe's installation jobs, have no upfront fee; Thumbtack keeps a percentage of the job price that it does not publish. Two toggles can add automatic charges. Smart Match may send leads outside your preferences, and lead boosts send extra matching leads at 25% off after you hit your budget, up to one per paid lead that week. Decline either kind before you reply to get the fee back, or turn the toggle off.
- Thumbtack's competition limit expires. Angi caps each request at five pros (Angi Help). Thumbtack's Quality Commitment terms (last updated September 28, 2026) cap contacts from search at five pros for the first four hours, and more pros can be contacted after that (Quality Commitment Terms).
Bad leads: Thumbtack refunds vs Angi credits
| Policy (as of November 2026) | Thumbtack | Angi |
|---|---|---|
| What you get back | Credit to your Thumbtack balance; back to your original payment method only if you ask within 10 business days of approval (Refund policy). | Credit toward future leads, no cash (Request a lead credit). |
| Time limit | Request within 45 days (Refund policy). | Lead under 45 days old, per the page updated August 14, 2026 (Request a lead credit). |
| Automatic or requested | Fair Shot refunds are automatic after 72 hours if no pro got a reply; leads flagged by Trust and Safety are refunded automatically; everything else is by request (Thumbtack numbers refund, Refund policy). | By request only (Request a lead credit). |
| What you must have done | For Fair Shot: replied within 4 business hours (8 a.m. to 8 p.m. local) through Thumbtack messenger or your Thumbtack number, without sharing your personal phone or email before the customer's first reply (Thumbtack numbers refund). | Tried to call within 24 hours; account in good standing (Request a lead credit). |
| Qualifying reasons | Invalid phone number, duplicate within 45 days, job changed significantly, fixed date outside your blocked calendar, lead breaks the Terms of Use, or an Opportunity customer whose first reply is "no thanks" (Refund policy). | Invalid contact info, wrong location, service mismatch, duplicate within 45 days, or charged while paused (Request a lead credit). |
| Annual plans | Not applicable (no annual plans). | No credits on annual subscriptions (Request a lead credit). |
| Decision and expiry | Usually 24 to 48 hours, up to 4 days, at Thumbtack's sole discretion (Refund policy). | Reviewed within 5 business days; credits expire after 6 months (Request a lead credit). |
On Angi, annual subscription plans get no lead credits at all, even for a wrong number or an out-of-area lead, and on pay-per-lead a lead you didn't try to call within 24 hours no longer qualifies. An older HomeAdvisor guidelines page still shows a 30-day window; Angi's current page says 45 days.
Thumbtack's Fair Shot refund, part of its Quality Commitment, covers a customer who replies to none of the pros. If the customer answers another pro and ignores you, neither platform's written policy gives the fee back.
What leads cost
Many comparison posts repeat undated third-party price ranges. As of November 2026, neither Thumbtack nor Angi publishes a fixed rate card.
Thumbtack uses two pricing models, depending on the account:
- Exact lead prices: you set a dollar price per service (Set lead prices).
- Smarter lead matching: you set one minimum and maximum per trade, and Thumbtack prices each lead inside that range based on estimated job value. Thumbtack says it never charges above your maximum (Smarter lead matching, New pro guide).
Prices also move. A junk removal pro on Reddit reported leads of $40 to $100+ in January 2025 after local prices doubled (r/Contractor). For the full breakdown, see how much Thumbtack charges for leads.
Angi does not publish per-lead rates. The one hard number comes from Angi's Q3 2026 results, reported in November 2026: $47 average revenue per lead, up 9.8% year over year (TradingKey, MarketBeat). It averages 4.5 million leads across every trade and market, so it won't tell you what your leads will cost.
Which one fits your business
Small, fast jobs and solo operators
For handyman work, cleaning, junk removal, lawn care and small repairs, a weekly spending cap matters most. As an illustration: at $50 per lead on a $220 job, winning one in five leads means $250 in lead fees for one $220 job. A January 2026 r/Contractor thread describes Angi and HomeAdvisor charging win or lose with four or five contractors on each lead, which painters there said their margins could not absorb (r/Contractor). A window cleaner turned down an Angi rep's quote of $300 to $400 a month for 14 to 24 leads, saying they already close about 98% of their Thumbtack leads (r/WindowCleaning, April 2025). For small tickets, Thumbtack's weekly budget, Fair Shot refunds and free-to-quote Opportunities make losses easier to cap.
Big-ticket trades (roofing, remodeling, HVAC)
Roofers, remodelers, HVAC shops and electricians make enough per project to absorb several leads that don't close, so Angi is a more reasonable test here. Results vary. A C-10 electrician on Reddit spent $500 a month on Angi without one decent lead and preferred Thumbtack because the weekly and per-lead caps are visible (r/Contractor, March 2026). Roofers in a February 2026 thread about leaving Angi said Thumbtack jobs tend to come down to the lowest price (r/Roofing). If you test Angi, stay on pay-per-lead.
Non-home categories (events, lessons, wellness)
Angi covers home services. Thumbtack lists 500+ categories as of November 2026, including events, lessons and wellness (Thumbtack About). If your work falls outside home services, Thumbtack is the only one of the two that fits.
How to test either for 30 days
- Avoid annual contracts. On Thumbtack, set a weekly budget (the last lead can go over by the lower of 40% or $40 + 2%, per Set budget) and turn off Smart Match and lead boosts if you only want strict matches. On Angi, use pay-per-lead so you keep credit rights (Request a lead credit).
- Reply and call fast. Thumbtack says pros who respond within 30 minutes are 25% more likely to get hired than pros who take three hours (2025 Pro Summit blog). Angi credits require a call attempt within 24 hours. Fair Shot requires a reply within four business hours through Thumbtack's messenger or number (Thumbtack numbers refund).
- Track cost per hire. Thumbtack shows what you paid per lead, not per hire. Tag each lead and note how it ended. A spreadsheet works; LeadsTagger is a free Chrome extension, not affiliated with Thumbtack, Angi or HomeAdvisor, that adds tags, private notes and follow-up dates inside the Thumbtack inbox and never sends messages. Its free report, built from Thumbtack's lead export, shows cost per lead and per hire.
- Request refunds or credits every week, well inside the 45-day window.
- At the end of the 30 days, divide net spend by jobs won and compare it with your profit per job. Is Thumbtack worth it for pros? walks through that math.
Frequently asked questions
Is Angi or Thumbtack better for contractors?
For most solo pros and small contractors, Thumbtack: no membership fee or contract, you set your own price or range, and Fair Shot refunds the lead automatically when a customer replies to no pro within 72 hours (Quality Commitment Terms). Angi can work for big-ticket home trades on pay-per-lead. Annual subscriptions get no lead credits (Request a lead credit).
Is HomeAdvisor the same as Angi?
Yes. Angie's List and HomeAdvisor are both part of Angi Inc. Angie's List was renamed Angi in March 2021, and HomeAdvisor's pro product became Angi Leads, according to Angi's annual report as summarized by Echvo and ProLicensed.
Does Angi charge for leads you don't respond to?
Yes. As of November 2026, Angi charges for a matched lead "whether or not you open or respond" (Opportunities and Leads FAQ), and a lead you didn't try to call within 24 hours doesn't qualify for a credit (Request a lead credit).
Does Thumbtack have a membership fee?
No. As of November 2026, Thumbtack charges no join, monthly or annual fee (Thumbtack for Pros). You pay per lead, per Opportunity the customer replies to, or a percentage of the job price on preset jobs (Types of leads).
Can I get refunds for bad Angi leads?
Angi gives credits toward future leads, not cash, and annual subscriptions get no credits as of November 2026 (Request a lead credit). On pay-per-lead, you can request a credit within 45 days for invalid contact info, wrong location, service mismatch, a duplicate or a charge while paused, as long as you tried to call within 24 hours. Credits expire after 6 months.
How many pros get the same Thumbtack lead?
As of November 2026, a customer can contact up to five pros from search in the first four hours, and more after that (Quality Commitment Terms). Opportunities close once five pros have shown interest or after 48 hours (Opportunities).