Skip to content
LeadsTagger

Guide for Thumbtack Pros

How to calculate your cost per hire on Thumbtack

To calculate your cost per hire on Thumbtack, open Performance → Download lead details on a desktop browser to export up to 12 months of your lead details CSV (as of November 2026), mark which leads became booked jobs, add up what you paid minus approved refunds, and divide by jobs won. That gives your lead cost per hire. Add Opportunities and subscriptions like Front Desk before dividing for an all-in figure.

Updated November 12, 2026 · Checked against the Thumbtack Help Center

The short answer

  • Lead cost per hire: (lead charges − refunds) ÷ jobs won.
  • All-in cost per hire: Add Opportunity fees and Thumbtack subscriptions (like Front Desk) to net spend before dividing by jobs won.
  • Export lead data: Download up to 12 months on desktop via Performance → Download lead details, as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help).
  • Check extra billing: Review Payments → Activity and Receipts for Opportunities, credits, and refunds (Thumbtack Help).
  • Count hires: Filter Messages by Job confirmed and Job done (Thumbtack Help).

Cost per lead vs cost per hire

Cost per lead is what you pay when one customer contacts you: depending on your account as of November 2026, either an exact price per service (Thumbtack Help) or a min-to-max range per trade (smarter lead matching). Cost per hire is your total lead spend per booked job, which decides your real Thumbtack ROI. For lead pricing and weekly budgets, see how much Thumbtack charges for leads.

Step 1: Download your lead details CSV

Your Performance dashboard updates every Monday with lead insights and average price (what you spent on leads), as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help). In the Pro app, open Services → View business insights to view that summary; CSV export is desktop only.

From a desktop browser (Thumbtack Help):

  1. Open the Performance tab.
  2. Click Download lead details (top right).
  3. Choose one business or All my businesses.
  4. Pick a Calendar year or Date range (up to 12 months at a time, as of November 2026).
  5. Click Download CSV file.

Each row includes the customer's name, phone number, amount paid (including taxes and discounts), and any refunds (Thumbtack Help). Thumbtack suggests using it for ROI tracking against job revenue, tax bookkeeping, past-lead follow-up, service-area tuning, and CRM or invoicing imports.

Store the CSV securely and use customer names and phone numbers only for your own bookkeeping and follow-up.

Step 2: Mark the leads you won

Your hire status lives in Messages. Under each customer's name, the status drop-down offers Not scheduled yet, Scheduled, Job done, and No hire, as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help).

Filter Messages via Inbox filters in the app (Messages → three-dot menu) or Folders on web, checking both Job confirmed and Job done (Thumbtack Help).

Open the CSV in a spreadsheet, add Won? (Y/N) and Job revenue columns, and mark Y next to each booked customer. For a weekly tracking routine, see how to track your Thumbtack leads.

Step 3: Add up what you actually paid

Thumbtack's help page states only that the CSV covers "each lead" (Thumbtack Help), without saying whether Opportunities, bookings, or preset-job fees appear in it. Cross-check Payments → Activity and Receipts (app: Profile → gear → Payments → View your balance and charges) as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help).

Charge or credit (as of November 2026)Include?Where to find it
Direct leads (incl. Smart Match) (Thumbtack Help, Smart Match)Yes (auto-paid)CSV; Payments → Activity
Lead boosts (Thumbtack Help)Yes (25% off past budget; refunded if declined before replying)Payments → Activity
Approved refunds (Fair Shot, Refund policy)Subtract once (Refunded or Credited only)CSV; Payments → Receipts
Opportunities (Thumbtack Help)Yes, all-in (billed to card outside budget if customer replies)Payments → Activity
Front Desk (Thumbtack Help)All-in only ($60 to $500/month)Your monthly Front Desk charge
Preset-job fees (Thumbtack Help, Preset jobs)No, track separately (unpublished % of payment; earnings shown upfront)The earnings shown before you claim the job
Credit-package bonus credit (Thumbtack Help)Note belowPayments → Receipts

Two billing notes:

  • Starter credit packages: New pros can buy a credit package with extra free credit (Thumbtack Help), and CSV amounts already reflect taxes and discounts (Thumbtack Help). Check Payments → Receipts for actual cash spent during a promo.
  • Instant deposit: Thumbtack's 1% instant-deposit fee as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help) is a payout fee, not a lead cost.

Step 4: Divide by jobs won

Thumbtack defines no official cost-per-hire metric, so use these two worksheet formulas:

Lead cost per hire = (lead charges − refunds) ÷ jobs won

All-in cost per hire = (lead charges + Opportunity charges + subscriptions − refunds) ÷ jobs won

Your hire rate is jobs won ÷ leads paid for.

In your spreadsheet:

  1. Add a net-cost column subtracting the refund column from the amount-paid column.
  2. Total net cost with SUM.
  3. Count wins with COUNTIF on Won? ("Y").
  4. Divide total net spend by jobs won.

Worked example (made-up round numbers): Suppose in one month you pay for 30 leads totaling $900, and get $120 back in Fair Shot and case-by-case refunds (Thumbtack Help). Net lead spend is $780 ($900 − $120).

You win 6 jobs from those 30 leads (20% hire rate). Your lead cost per hire is $130 ($780 ÷ 6). Add a $60 Front Desk plan and $0 in Opportunities, and total spend is $840, making your all-in cost per hire $140 ($840 ÷ 6).

Split it by service and month

One blended average can hide a losing service behind a strong one. Add a Service column beside Won? and Job revenue, then build a pivot table (or use SUMIFS and COUNTIFS) grouped by Service and lead month.

Using the same example:

Service (example)Paid leadsGross chargesRefundsNet spendJobs wonLead cost per hire
Service A18$540$60$4805$96
Service B12$360$60$3001$300
Total30$900$120$7806$130

Blended together, $130 per hire may look fine. Split apart, Service A wins jobs for $96 while Service B burns $300 for one hire, showing where to adjust prices, tighten preferences, or pause a service.

Mistakes that make the number wrong

  1. Counting refunds twice. Refunds go to your Thumbtack balance by default unless you request a return to your payment method within 10 business days of approval, as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help, How to request a refund). Leads later paid from that credit are still real spend; subtract a refund once when approved, not again when spent. See Thumbtack refund policy for pros for the 45-day rules.
  2. Using gross prices instead of net. Skipping refunds overstates cost; deducting Pending or Denied requests understates it. Subtract only Refunded or Credited items (Thumbtack Help).
  3. Counting hires by job date. An October lead can book in November. We suggest matching hires to the lead's month (cohort tracking), or waiting about 30 days before closing a month.
  4. Judging tiny samples. With 4 hires, one extra job swings the average sharply. Review three months together before changing settings.
  5. Forgetting Opportunities. Opportunities bill your payment method outside your weekly budget. Add them from Payments → Activity (Thumbtack Help) along with any jobs won.
  6. Mixing preset jobs in. Preset jobs take a cut of the job payment, not a lead fee. Counting them in jobs won artificially lowers lead cost per hire; track them separately.

What to compare your cost per hire with

Thumbtack publishes no average hire rate or benchmark cost per hire. Job sizes, margins, and competition vary too widely across trades for a universal target to work.

Compare your number against two internal benchmarks:

  • Profit per job: Subtract labor, materials, and travel from average job revenue. That profit is the most you can pay per hire without losing money; see is Thumbtack worth it for pros? for the full break-even math.
  • Your own trend: Track three-month rolling figures per service to spot rising lead costs or slipping close rates early.

Let a tool do the math

Updating a monthly sheet works, though matching inbox threads to CSV rows takes routine effort.

If you'd rather not build the spreadsheet, LeadsTagger is a free Chrome extension, not affiliated with Thumbtack, that reads the lead details CSV and shows cost per lead and cost per hire after refunds, by month. In your Thumbtack inbox it also lets you tag each lead as hired or lost. It only reads your data and never sends messages or changes your account.

Frequently asked questions

How do I download my lead details from Thumbtack?

On desktop, open Performance → Download lead details, pick a business or All my businesses, choose a Calendar year or Date range up to 12 months, and click Download CSV file, as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help). Mobile export isn't available.

Does Thumbtack show my cost per hire?

Thumbtack's help pages state that the Performance dashboard updates every Monday with lead insights and average price spent on leads, as of November 2026 (Thumbtack Help). No cost-per-hire figure is stated, so calculate it yourself from net spend and jobs won.

Should refunds be subtracted?

Yes, once. Subtract Refunded or Credited fees from gross lead charges (Thumbtack Help). Refunds go to your Thumbtack balance by default (Thumbtack Help), so don't subtract a refund again when that credit pays for a later lead.

Do Opportunities count?

Yes, for all-in cost per hire along with any jobs won from them. Opportunities bill your payment method outside your weekly budget when you reach out and the customer responds (Thumbtack Help), and appear in Payments → Activity (Thumbtack Help).

What's a good cost per hire on Thumbtack?

Thumbtack publishes no benchmark cost per hire or hire rate. Keep your cost per hire comfortably below your profit per job after labor, materials, and travel; see is Thumbtack worth it for pros?.

How often should I calculate it?

We suggest updating your sheet monthly after Monday's Performance refresh (Thumbtack Help), and reviewing three months together so slow weeks or late-booking leads don't skew your decisions.